Home » community » News » Marketing Performance: Embracing the Measurable and Unmeasurable

Marketing Performance: Embracing the Measurable and Unmeasurable

Marketing performance is more than just numbers; it’s about striking the right balance between data-driven insights and the intangible qualities that create brand loyalty and recognition. As a business owner, understanding which marketing elements can be quantified and which cannot is crucial for making effective decisions about your marketing strategy. There’s plenty to explore on both sides of marketing performance—those measurable aspects that provide critical metrics and those unmeasurable ones that shape how your brand is perceived.

The Importance of Marketing Performance Reporting

Before we continue, don’t fall into the notion that reporting is a waste of time. Reporting on marketing performance offers peace of mind and valuable insights that guides your strategy and spend. Measuring key metrics drives accountability, particularly where third party providers are in the picture (e.g. Google Ads specialists). You can also use data to make informed adjustments to your marketing spend, ensuring it is optimised and driving business growth. Integrating these metrics with financial management reporting gives you a complete picture of how your marketing activities impact your bottom line.

Marketing metrics are not only indicators of success but also tools to maintain momentum. From tracking website traffic to lead generation, reporting allows businesses to continually optimise their marketing strategy and refine how each dollar is allocated.

What Can Be Measured: Key Metrics for Marketing Performance

Traffic and Engagement

Website traffic and social media engagement provide a strong foundation for understanding marketing performance. Tools like Google Analytics reveal how audiences find your website online, their journey through your site, how long they stay, and what actions they take. Social media platforms offer metrics on engagement, including likes, shares, and comments, allowing you to gauge brand visibility and resonance. The prevalence of publishing and reporting tools like Sprout Social and Hootsuite make the management or content and reporting side of social media marketing easy and efficient. That’s why measuring those channels is a no brainer – the time investment is minimal but the data you collect allows you to determine whether social media is an effective place for your business to advertise.

Lead Generation and Conversion Rates

Lead generation is the backbone of effective marketing. Tracking the number of leads, their sources (e.g., website, Google search, outdoor advertising, radio, TV, billboards, social media, referrals), and their conversion rates offers insight into how well marketing efforts drive actual business outcomes. Key elements to measure include:

• Quantity of Leads – How many are generated within a specific period.
• Quality of Leads – Distinguishing between qualified and unqualified leads to focus resources on higher-value prospects.
• Conversion Metrics – Understanding which leads convert to clients and the value they bring, contributing directly to ROI.

Financial Metrics: Return on Investment

ROI is one of the most tangible indicators of marketing performance, tracking the revenue generated for each dollar spent. Advertising expenses, cost per lead, and cost per acquisition (CPA) are critical metrics. These figures can form part of broader management reporting and be correlated directly to profit and loss (P&L) statements, making marketing performance an integral part of your overall business strategy.

Beyond the Numbers: Unmeasurable Elements That Shape Brand Impact

Brand Loyalty and Recognition

While metrics like website traffic are essential, brand loyalty and recognition are difficult to quantify but invaluable in the long term. Loyal customers are likely to make repeat purchases and recommend your brand to others, even without tangible data to validate it. Brand recognition—the ease with which consumers recall your brand and associate it with trust—strengthens market positioning.

Brand Voice and Consistency

A consistent brand voice can distinguish your business and foster trust among your audience, though it may not be directly measurable. The tone, language, and style of communication your brand uses in content, emails, and social media convey values that resonate with your audience. While you may track engagement rates, the impact of a unique brand voice often shows up in customer loyalty and perception over time, rather than in specific data points. If further insights into the importance of consistency in marketing is of interest, check this out.

Why Measuring Everything Isn’t Practical

As marketing evolves, so does our ability to measure a vast array of metrics. However, measuring everything can become a costly distraction, diverting attention and resources from the overarching business goals. Renowned marketing strategist Rory Sutherland suggests that “the trouble with the obsession with measurement and data is that it leaves out human understanding.” Sutherland argues that while data is crucial, over-reliance can undermine creativity and the nuanced, emotional connections brands aim to build with their customers.

Focusing on the right metrics—those that directly impact revenue and client acquisition—ensures your marketing efforts remain efficient and effective. Attempting to quantify every aspect of marketing is neither possible nor necessary. Instead, by honing in on key performance indicators (KPIs) that align with business goals, you can make informed decisions without losing sight of your brand’s unique personality and appeal.

Integrating Measurable and Unmeasurable Data for Holistic Marketing Performance

Effective marketing blends measurable data with unmeasurable qualities. By incorporating both, businesses can create campaigns that not only drive traffic and conversions but also build long-term loyalty and brand equity. Prioritising measurable aspects without neglecting intangible qualities allows for a balanced approach, ultimately leading to more effective and authentic marketing.

Final Thoughts: A Balanced Approach to Marketing Performance

In today’s data-driven world, measurable top-of-the-funnel marketing metrics are invaluable. Yet, focusing solely on numbers can lead to a disconnection from the deeper elements that make a brand memorable and drive bottom-of-the-funnel results like loyalty and advocacy. As a business owner, balance is key: invest in tracking the metrics that matter but recognise the importance of unmeasurable qualities. Combine data-driven insights with human understanding, and your marketing efforts will not only drive performance but foster relationships that contribute to sustained growth and brand success.

Further Reading/Listening: Rory Sutherland’s Insight on Behavior and Data – CleverTap

written by:

Ben Hart

Ben joined the McKinley Plowman team in 2017 as a Marketing & HR Assistant, after completing a Bachelors degree in Marketing & Management from the University of Western Australia. Ben has since stepped up to the role of Marketing Manager and oversees the marketing activities for MP+ and many of our clients.

Ben enjoys helping clients take their businesses to the next level with thoughtful marketing strategies, innovative solutions, and timely reviews to ensure great outcomes. When he's not in the office, you'll find Ben playing football (soccer), watching it, or reading about it.